How to argue about abortion by john noonan essay

In the case of the anti-abortion, male, whose written papers on the Catholic take on the matter, there was little to no mention of any concern to the pregnant woman.

How to argue about abortion by john noonan essay

Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues. Although there are many sides to the topic, the issue has divided the majority of people to the two extreme views of the topic —Pro-choice Vs.

We can see the main arguments of each side just by analyzing the titles given to the two sides. Those who are pro-life believe that they are in fact Pro-Life and that abortion is murder.

Feelings and emotions about such an issue are very powerful and it has been the case that both sides will go to extremes to defend what they believe in. Such was the case Rosalie and Hector Zevallos, owners of an abortion clinic who were kidnapped and threatened with their lives, if they would not close down their clinic.

How to argue about abortion by john noonan essay

Glover, CC, 22 John Noonan is an abbot supporter of the pro-life movement and in his essay, How to Argue About Abortion, he provides many arguments to support his theory that abortion is nothing but the destruction of a living, breathing human being. Noonan attempts to prove his point by first showing counter arguments to many of the traditional pro-choice themes that have been brought up over and over in support of abortion.

He then goes on to mention many arguments that he feels can clearly illustrate the logical reasoning of the pro-life movement. The main point of this discussion is in the case of Rape.

The pro-choice movement argues that a women is not responsible for a child that was conceived when the women was raped and therefore can not be held responsible to carry and take care of the child.

Noonan argues that, first of all, the whole Rape issue is cited as a racist ploy to suggest that a baby can not be allowed to live when a black man rapes a white women Noonan, CC, p Noonan suggest that the argument is brought up to play on the racist emotions of many Americans in this country.

It is not fair to the fetus that he die, because his mother experiences certain emotions whenever she notices the fetus.

'How to Argue About Abortion' by John Noonan | Essay Example

If the mother can not control the psychological pressures of the child being a constant reminder of the traumatic experience, then the child should be adopted, not die. Meaning that if, for example, abortion was outlawed and only permitted in the case of rape, then those who had casual sex and were now facing an unplanned pregnancy would claim rape in order to abort the child.

One of the central topics discussed by both sides is whether or not, we can say that the fetus is life and therefore can abortion be considered murder. Opponents of the anti abortion movement suggest that abortion of the fetus can not be considered murder because the fetus is not a yet human life.

A human being has had many experiences and is self aware and therefore can not be killed whereas the fetus has had no experiences and is not self aware and therefore can be aborted. Noonan argues that experience is not a reliable method to measure life.

These are all experiences that the baby is experiencing and if it is wrong to kill an experienced human being, then it is wrong to abort a fetus Noonan, CC, p Noonan also argues that psychologically, we humans respond to what we can see and if we can truly see a fetus, we can see life Noonan, CC, p Another major criticism brought up by the pro-life movement is that men should not be making decision and expressing their opinion about the topic of abortion simply because they are not the ones who experience child birth and having to abort the child.

Noonan, CC, p19 This statement implies that we can judge things as morally wrong or right even if we do not experience the situation ourselves.

In addition to counter arguing many of the central themes of the Pro-choice supporters, Noonan goes on to display arguments that would support the pro-life movement. Noonan mentions the fact that everyone in the world has one kind of opinion or another for every argument, and that each person has some kind of a logic for their claims Noonan, CC, p Often these claims clash with one another and often the reasoning and logic behind these claims are untrustworthy.

Therefore to get at a central answer, we can not just listen to reasoning but instead look within ourselves for a higher answer. Noonan argues that our emotions and tastes are basic and can not be disputed Noonan, CC, p If we do this, we will realize that killing is wrong and humanity will not allow us to destroy the child.

This is blood that only you can provide and if you unplug the violinist, he will die. The moral question being answered here is that even if the pro-life supporters are correct in their theory that abortion is death, it does not mean that the mother is obligated to attach herself to the baby and support it, specially if the baby is unwanted or is conceived through Rape which is analogous to the fact that boy plugged into the violinist was forcibly kidnapped.Essay analyzing the book 'How to Argue About Abortion' by John Noonan.

Essay also analyzes the topic of Pro-Choice Vs. Pro-Life. of the pro-life movement. One of Noonan's first topics to discuss is that of "hard cases" which the pro-choice movement argues are valid reasons as to why abortion should be available.

The main point of this. A Critique of John T. Noonan's an Almost Absolute Value in History Words Aug 11th, 6 Pages A Critique of An Almost Absolute Value in History “An Almost Absolute Value in History,” by John Noonan, argues against the morality of abortion at any time during a pregnancy.

‘How to Argue About Abortion’ by John Noonan Essay Sample

Noonan and Warrens Views on Abortion Essay. John Noonan and Mary Ann Warren believe the most fundamental question involved in the long history of abortion is.

How do you determine the humanity of a being?

How to argue about abortion by john noonan essay

They both use their views on the answer to argue their positions on abortion. Jane English differs from many pro- and anti-abortion /5(1).

an almost absolute value in history, by John T. Noonan, Jr. [1]The most fundamental question involved in the long history of thought on abortion is: How do you determine the humanity of a being? From John T. Noonan, Jr. ed., For Gustafson, the choice of abortion under some circumstances may be paralleled not so much to the perfectly pacifistic Jesus on the cross, but the Christian soldier, for whom life may be taken in a just war - . (In the essay that follows, the remarks in parenthesis in red are my remarksDr. Armstrong) AN ALMOST ABSOLUTE VALUE IN HISTORY, by John T. Noonan, Jr.

From John T. Noonan, Jr. ed., For Gustafson, the choice of abortion under some circumstances may be paralleled not so much to the perfectly pacifistic Jesus on the cross, but the Christian soldier, for whom life may be taken in a just war - .

Abortion-Noonan Essay Jessica Bratsch Ethics-Paper 2 “An almost absolute value in history” by John Noonan “A defense of abortion” by Judith Thomson “On the legal and moral stance of abortion” by Mary Anne Warren According to John Noonan, human beings should not be aborted.

He discusses whether or not an embryo or fetus is. A Critique of John T. Noonan's an Almost Absolute Value in History Words Aug 11th, 6 Pages A Critique of An Almost Absolute Value in History “An Almost Absolute Value in History,” by John Noonan, argues against the morality of abortion at any time during a pregnancy.

Noonan and Catholic Perspectives