October 3, at 4: The former is refined, and is aimed at perfection, accepting flaws whenever red flags are raised. The latter is raw and tasteless, but is surprisingly yet still appreciate by many, even if eaten raw. The result of this:
Could they fool scholarly journals into publishing hoax papers masquerading as legitimate scholarship? The answer, it turns out, was yes. Seven journals accepted the fake papers, which Spoof research papers written by James Lindsay, a mathematician; Helen Pluckrose, editor of Areo; and Peter Boghossian, an assistant professor of philosophy at Portland State University.
Four of the papers have been published, according to The Wall Street Journal: One of the trio's hoax papers, published in April by the journal Fat Studies, claims bodybuilding is "fat-exclusionary" and proposes "a new classification So I am surprised that, of all things, they'd write this as a hoax.
As you can imagine, this is a very serious charge. A hoax paper for the Journal of Poetry Therapy describes monthly feminist spirituality meetings, complete with a "womb room," and discusses six poems, which Mr. Lindsay generated by algorithm and lightly edited. Founding editor Nicholas Mazza said the article went through blind peer review and revisions before its acceptance in July, but he regrets not doing more to verify the author's identity.
He added that it took years to build credibility and get the Journal of Poetry Therapy listed in major scholarly databases. Still, "I can see how editors like me and journals can be duped. In addition to the papers on fat studies, feminism spirituality, and neoliberal choice feminism, Lindsay, Pluckrose, and Boghossian also found a home for a fourth paper, "Rape Culture and Queer Performativity at Urban Dog Parks.
While the title sounded absurd on its face, its author, the fictitious "Helen Wilson," purported to have compiled an impressive amount of data regarding her observations of canine sexual aggression at dog parks. Wilson claimed to be affiliated with the Portland Ungendering Research Initiative, which had a domain name but no operating website.
As I wrote at the time, many of Wilson's conclusions were unwarranted, and the whole thing was written in incomprehensible social-justice gobbledygook, but the underlying data seemed to have some potential meaning, even if the author was applying it poorly: Wilson spent hours in three dog parks, where she made note of a whole bunch of times when one dog humped another.
When the humping was male-on-male, owners intervened in the overwhelming number of cases. But when the humping was male-on-female, owners were far less likely to stop it.
This, the study suggests, might say something about the owners' internalized homophobia and their willingness to overlook female victims of sexual assault. At Areothe authors claim that the dog park study's shortcomings should have been glaringly obvious because the statistics were "improbable," and advanced "highly dubious ethics including training men like dogs.
As for the ethics involved, we-should-train-men-like-dogs is indeed a silly proposition, but researchers should feel comfortable exploring and testing crazy premises. Now who's being too P.My research also focused on the distribution coefficient which is a measurement of how much of a solvent is [absorbed] by a geologic medium.” “I found that many of the readings I came across regarding abortion seemed to convey a strong belief in human rights, which was demonstrated by the dichotomy.
A spoof medical paper full of easily detectable flaws was submitted in a sting operation to open access journals and accepted by more than half of them.
The results, reported in Science1 by journalist John Bohannon, reveal “an emerging Wild West in academic publishing,” he says, with.
Nov 15, · Papers by Alan Sokal on science, philosophy and culture "Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity" This is the original "parody" article, published in Social Text #46/47, pp. (spring/summer ). • Higgs would not have found his boson in today's publish-or-perish research culture.
Ian Sample. These papers are so funny, you read them and can't help but . The Sokal affair, also called the Sokal hoax, was a scholarly publishing sting perpetrated by Alan Sokal, a physics professor at New York University and University College London.
In , Sokal submitted an article to Social Text, . Search our database for more Spoof downloadable research papers. InfoSci-OnDemand Download Premium Research Papers Full text search our database of , titles for Spoof to find related research papers.
Learn More About Spoof in These Related Titles.